Full Text
REGD. No. D. L.-33004/99
The Gazette of India
CG-DL-E-01012024-251035
EXTRAORDINARY
PART I—Section 1
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
No. 325]
NEW DELHI, FRIDAY, DECEMBER 29, 2023
8053 GI/2023
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY
(Department of Commerce)
(DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF TRADE REMEDIES)
INITIATION NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 29th December, 2023
(Case No. CVD-SSR- 13/2023)
Subject: Initiation of sunset review investigation of countervailing duty concerning imports of "new pneumatic
radial tyres for buses and lorries” originating in or exported from China PR
F. No. 7/30/2023-DGTR.-Automotive Tyres Manufacturers Association ("ATMA") has filed an
application on behalf of the domestic producers namely Apollo Tyres Limited, J.K. Tyre Industries Limited and MRF
Limited (hereinafter collectively referred to as “applicants") before the Designated Authority (hereinafter referred to
as the "Authority") under the provisions of the Customs Tariff Act 1975, as amended from time to time (hereinafter
also referred to as the "Act") and the Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Countervailing
Duty on Subsidized Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995 thereof, as amended from time to time
(hereinafter also referred to as the "CVD Rules" or "Rules") for the initiation of a sunset review investigation of
countervailing duties concerning imports of "new pneumatic radial tyres for buses and lorries" (hereinafter referred to
as the "subject goods" or "product under consideration") originating in or exported from China PR (hereinafter
referred to as the "subject country").
2. In terms of Section 9 (6) of the Act and Rule 24 (3) of the CVD Rules, the countervailing duties imposed
shall, unless revoked earlier, cease to have effect on expiry of five years from the date of such imposition, and the
Authority is required to review whether the expiry of the said countervailing duty is likely to lead to continuation
or recurrence of subsidisation and injury to the domestic industry. In accordance with the same, the Authority is
required to review, on the basis of duly substantiated request made by or on behalf of the domestic industry as to
whether there is a need for the continued imposition of the countervailing duty, and whether the expiry of the duty
is likely to lead to continuation or recurrence of subsidisation and injury.
3. In terms of Article 13 of the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures, pre-initiation
consultations were held with the officials of the Government of China on 15th December, 2023. The Government
of China has alleged that the evidence provided in the application regarding subsidy programs is insufficient. The
Authority notes that Article 11.2 of the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures provides that “the
application shall contain such information as is reasonably available to the applicant”. The Authority considers
that the existence of all alleged programs, their countervailability and extent of benefit therein are required to be
analysed through an investigation as per the relevant rules.
A. Background
4. The original anti-subsidy investigation was initiated by the Authority on 27th March 2018. The Authority
recommended the imposition of definitive anti-subsidy duties on the imports of the subject goods from the subject
countries vide final finding No. 6/8/2018-DGAD dated 25th March 2019. The definitive measures were imposed
by the Ministry of Finance vide Customs Notification No. 1/2019-Customs (CVD), dated 24th June 2019.
5. Further, pursuant to a request by filed by the exporters M/s. Shandong Haohua Tire Co. Ltd., China PR
along with Guangzhou Exceed Industrial Technology Co. Ltd., China PR and HK Trade Wind Trading Limited,
Hong Kong, the Authority initiated new shipper review investigation vide notification dated 20th April 2020 for
determination of individual countervailing duty. In view of the request received from these exporters for
withdrawal of their application, the Authority terminated the new shipper investigation vide notification dated 4th
March 2021.
B. Product under Consideration
6. The product under consideration is the same as in the original investigation i.e., “New/Unused pneumatic
radial tyres with or without tubes and/or flap of rubber (including tubeless tyres), having nominal rim dia code
above 16" used in buses and lorries/trucks".
7. The present investigation being a sunset review investigation, the scope of the product under
consideration remains the same as defined in the original investigation.
8. The product under consideration is classified under Chapter 40 of the First Schedule to the Customs
Tariff Act, 1975. Tyres are classified under HS code 40112010 and tubes and flaps are classified under HS codes
40131020 and 40129049 respectively. The product under consideration is also being imported under the HS code
40118000. The customs classification is only indicative and is not binding on the scope of the present
investigation. The Authority shall consider imports of the product under consideration, irrespective of its
classification for the purpose of the proposed determination.
C. Like Article
9. The applicants have claimed that there are no known significant differences in the goods produced by the
petitioning domestic producers and that exported from the subject countries. Both products have comparable
characteristics in terms of parameters such as physical & chemical characteristics, manufacturing process &
technology, functions & uses, product specifications, pricing, distribution & marketing and tariff classification.
The applicants have claimed that the two are technically and commercially substitutable. Therefore, for the
purpose of present investigation, the subject goods produced by the petitioning domestic producers are being
treated as 'like article' to the subject goods originating in or exported from the subject countries.
D. Domestic Industry and Standing
10. The application has been filed by Automotive Tyre Manufacturer's Association on behalf of the domestic
producers of the product namely, Apollo Tyres Limited, J.K. Tyre Industries Limited and MRF Limited. As per
the evidence available on record, production of the applicants, being more than 50% of Indian production,
accounts for a major proportion of the total domestic production. The Authority determines that the constituent
domestic producers in the present application namely Apollo Tyres Limited, J.K. Tyre Industries Limited and
MRF Limited constitute domestic industry as defined under Rule 2(b) of the CVD Rules.
E. Subsidy Programs
11. The applicants have alleged that the producers/ exporters of the subject goods in the subject countries
continue to be benefitted from actionable subsidies provided at various levels by the Governments of the subject
countries, including the provinces and districts in which producers/exporters are located. The applicants have also
claimed that there are additional programs or schemes that should be considered in the present investigation.
I. Schemes previously countervailed in the Original Investigation
a. Programs in the Form of Grants
i. Program No. 1: Fixed Asset Investment Subsidies
ii. Program No. 2: Reimbursement of Anti-dumping and/or Countervailing Legal Expenses by the
Local Governments
iii. Program No. 3: Special fund for foreign economic and trade development
iv. Program No. 4: Export Assistance Grant
V. Program No. 5: Subsidies for Companies Located in the Hefei Economic and Technology
Development Zone
vi. Program No. 6: Anhui Province Subsidies for Foreign-Invested Enterprises
vii. Program No. 7: Hefei Municipal Export Promotion Policies
viii. Program No. 8: Various subsidy programs for enterprises located in Hangzhou Economic and
Technology Development Area
ix. Program No. 9: Funds for “Outward Expansion" of Industries in Guangdong Province
Χ. Program No. 10: Research and Development Assistance Grant
xi. Program No.11: Fund for Industrial Transformation and Upgrading / Grants related to
technological upgrading, renovation or transformation
xii. Program No. 12: Special funds for energy saving technology reform / promotion of circular
economy/ incentive fund for transformation of energy-saving technology
xiii. Program No. 13: Grants for purchase of equipments
xiv. Program No. 14: Special funds for infrastructure construction
XV. Program No. 15: Various Government grants- Received by producers/exporters of China PR/
Ad hoc grants provided by central, provincial and municipal/regional authorities
xvi. Program No. 16: Grant for Bringing in Foreign Intellectuals
xvii. Program No. 17: Grants for Employment Stabilization, Graduates Training and recruitment
provided by provincial/prefectural/municipal government authorities
xviii. Program No. 18: Postdoctoral researchers funding
xix. Program No. 19: Grants for maintenance and operation of equipments
XX. Program No. 20: Relocation Compensation provided by provincial/prefectural/municipal
government authorities
xxi. Program No. 21: Ad-hoc grants for implementing specialized projects/pilot projects provided
by provincial/prefectural/municipal government authorities
xxii. Program No. 22: Grants/Awards for Industrial Design
xxiii. Program No. 23: Grants/Awards for Technological Innovation
xxiv. Program No. 24: Talent introduction fund
XXV. Program No. 25: Research report writing expenditure refund
xxvi. Program No. 26: Service industry development fund
xxvii. Program No. 27: Self-owned Brand Development Registration Fee refund
xxviii. Program No. 28: Import Equipment interest subsidy
xxix. Program No. 29: Export Rewards
XXX. Program No. 30: Patent Creation and Support Fund
xxxi. Program No. 31: Listing Fee Grant
xxxii. Program No. 32: Subsidies for listed companies
xxxiii. Program No. 33: Shandong Province Key Industry Technical Reform Project Loan Financial
Discount Interest Fund
xxxiv. Program No. 34: Nanhai New District Industrial Park Land Special Fund
XXXV. Program No. 35: Grants for financing loans and interest
xxxvi. Program No. 36: Special funds for land in Nanhai New District Industrial Park
b. Programs in the form of Tax and Vat Incentives
xxxvii. Program No. 37: Tax Policies for the deduction of research and development (R&D) expenses
xxxviii. Program No. 38: Preferential tax policies/ Income Tax Reductions for companies that are
recognized as high and new technology companies
xxxix. Program No. 39: Tax credit concerning the purchase of special equipment
c. Programs in the Form of Preferential Loans and Lending
xl. Program No. 40: Government Policy Lending
xli. Program No. 41: Preferential Loans to State Owned Enterprises
xlii. Program No. 42: Discounted Loans for Export-Oriented Enterprises and Export Loan Interest
Subsidies
xliii. Program No. 43: Preferential loans and interest rates to the Tyre Industry
d. Programs in the form of Export Financing and Export Credit
xliv. Program No. 44: Export Credit Insurance Subsidy
xlv. Program No. 45: Export Seller's Credit
xlvi. Program No. 46: Export Buyer's Credit
xlvii. Program No. 47: Other Export Financing from State-Owned Banks
e. Programs in the Form of Provision of Goods and Services at Less Than Adequate Remuneration
(LTAR)
xlviii. Program No. 48: Provision of Electricity for Less Than Adequate Remuneration
xlix. Program No. 49: Land Use Rights at LTAR in Industrial and Other Special Economic Zone
1. Program No. 50: Provision of Land to State Owned Enterprises at LTAR
li. Program No. 51: Land Use rights at LTAR for Foreign Invested Enterprises
lii. Program No. 52: Land-Use Rights at LTAR in Economic Development Zones
liii. Program No. 53: Provision of Carbon Black for Less Than Adequate Remuneration
II. New Subsidy Programs
a. Programs in the Form of Grants
i. Program No. 54: National Award for Green Factory
ii. Program No. 55: Famous Brands of China recognized by central, provincial or
municipal/regional authorities
iii. Program No. 56: Compensation for land acquisition and demolition spending funds
iv. Program No. 57: Funds for making investments in overseas subsidiaries
V. Program No. 58: Department of Commerce exchange rate subsidies
vi. Program No. 59: Grants for fixed asset investment for enterprises in Hubei
vii. Program No. 60: Special Fund for High-quality Development for enterprises located in Hubei
viii. Program No. 61: Road Transportation Subsidy
ix. Program No. 62: Intellectual Property Awards provided by provincial/prefectural/municipal
government authorities
Χ. Program No. 63: Special funds for high-tech enterprises in Yantai Economic Development Zone
xi. Program No. 64: Electricity subsidy
xii. Program No. 65: Enterprise social security subsidy
xiii. Program No. 66: Transformation and upgrading of key export industries
xiv. Program No. 67: Incentive funds/ Awards for increasing production and efficiency of key
enterprises
XV. Program No. 68: Incentive funds for Expansion of production-oriented export enterprises
xvi. Program No. 69: Industrial enterprise disaster relief funds
b. Programs in the form of Tax and Vat Incentives
xvii. Program No. 70: Export tax rebate/Tax Refund on Exports
xviii. Program No. 71: Accelerated depreciation of fixed assets
xix. Program No. 72: Tax incentives on urban land use tax for high tech enterprises
XX. Program No. 73: Refund/Rebate/Remission of taxes and fees by central, provincial or
municipal/regional governmental authorities
xxi. Program No. 74: Import Tariff/Charges and VAT Relief for Imported Equipment
xxii. Program No. 75: Import Tariff/Charges and VAT Relief for Imported Inputs
c. Programs in the form of Equity Infusion
xxiii. Program No. 76: Grant of Shares in Prometeon Tyre Group S.r.l. to Aeolus Tyres by ChemChina
xxiv. Program No. 77: Preferential Financing under One Belt One Road Initiative for Companies
making Outward Investments
XXV. Program No. 78: Debt for Equity Swaps
d. Programs in the Form of Provision of Goods and Services at Less Than Adequate Remuneration
(LTAR)
xxvi. Program No. 79: Provision of Nylon Tyre Cord Fabric for Less Than Adequate Remuneration
xxvii. Program No. 80: Provision of Synthetic Rubber for Less Than Adequate Remuneration
xxviii. Program No. 81: Provision of Natural Rubber for Less than Adequate Remuneration
e. Programs in the Form of Preferential Financing
xxix. Program No. 82: Provision of Loan Guarantee/Credit Loan Guarantee/Export Credit Guarantee
by GOC/ State owned Banks
12. The Designated Authority may investigate other subsidies, which may be found to exist and availed by
the producers/ exporters of the subject goods in the subject countries, during the course of the investigation.
F. Likelihood of continuation/recurrence of subsidy and injury
13. There is prima facie evidence of likelihood of continuation/recurrence of subsidization and consequent
injury to the domestic industry in the event of cessation of anti-subsidy duty, considering third country exports at
prices lower than the export price to India and non-injurious price of the domestic industry, trade remedial
measures imposed by third countries, capacity additions in the subject country, likely suppression or depression
effect of imports in the absence of duties, and likely adverse impact of cessation of anti-subsidy duty on the
performance of the domestic industry.
G. Initiation of sunset review investigation
14. On the basis of the duly substantiated application by or on behalf of the domestic industry, and having
satisfied itself, on the basis of the prima facie evidence submitted by the applicants, substantiating likelihood of
continuation or recurrence of subsidization and injury to the domestic industry, the Authority hereby initiates a
sunset review investigation to review the need for continued imposition of countervailing duty on imports of the
subject goods from the subject country and to examine whether the expiry of the existing countervailing duty is
likely to lead to continuation or recurrence of subsidy and consequent injury to the domestic industry, in
accordance with Section 9 of the Act, read with Rule 24 of the CVD Rules.
H. Subject countries
15. The subject country for the present countervailing duty investigation is China PR.
I. Period of investigation
16. The applicants have proposed period of investigation as 1st April 2022 to 30th June 2023 (15 months) for
the purpose of the present investigation. The applicants have submitted that consideration of July 2022 – June
2023 as the investigation period would result in significant practical difficulties for the preparation of the costing
data for the applicant domestic industry as these are multi-product companies having several plants. The applicant
companies further submitted that there would be no material difference in the merits of the case as the present
case is based on continuation of subsidies and likelihood of injury which do not have any bearing on the period
considered as POI. The Authority examined import volume and import price from the DGCI&S data considering
the period April 2022 to June 2023 (annualised) and July 2022 to June 2023. It was observed that there was no
material difference between import volume, value and CIF price. In addition, the present investigation is
concerning likelihood of continuation/recurrence of subsidies and injury. The Authority has therefore, accepted
the period of investigation proposed by the applicants which is 1st April 2022 to 30th June 2023 (15 months).
17. The injury investigation period has been considered as the period of investigation and the three preceding
financial years, i.e. 2019-20, 2020-21, 2021-22.
J. Procedure
18. The sunset review investigation will cover all aspects of the final findings published vide Notification
No. 6/8/2018-DGAD dated 25th March 2019. The Authority will also undertake likelihood analysis of
continuation/ recurrence of subsidization and injury in the event of expiry of countervailing duty in force.
19. The provisions of Rules 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19, 20, 21 and 22 shall apply mutatis mutandis in the
present investigation.
K. Submission of Information
20. All communication should be sent to the Authority via email at the email addresses [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected]. It should be ensured that the narrative part of the
submission is in searchable PDF/MS Word format and data files are in MS Excel format.
21. The known producers/exporters form the subject country, their government through their embassy in
India, the importers and users in India known to be concerned with the subject goods and the domestic producers
are being informed separately to enable them to file all the relevant information in the form and manner
prescribed within the time-limit set out below.
22. Any other interested party may also make its submissions relevant to the investigation in the form and
manner prescribed within the time-limit set out below on the email addresses mentioned hereinabove.
23. Any party making any confidential submission before the Authority is required to make a non-
confidential version of the same available to the other interested parties.
24. Interested parties are further advised to keep a regular watch on the official website of the Authority
http://www.dgtr.gov.in/ for any updated information with respect to this investigation.
L. Time Limit
25. Any information relating to the present investigation should be sent to the Authority via email at the
email addresses [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] within thirty days
(30 days) from the date of receipt of the notice as per Rule 7(4) of the CVD Rules. It may, however, be noted that
in terms of explanation of the said Rule, the notice calling for information and other documents shall be deemed
to have been received within one week from the date on which it was sent by the Designated Authority or
transmitted to the appropriate diplomatic representative of the exporting country. If no information is received
within the prescribed time limit or the information received is incomplete, the Authority may record its finding on
the basis of the facts available on records in accordance with the Rules.
26. All the interested parties are hereby advised to intimate their interest (including the nature of interest) in
the instant investigation and file their questionnaire response/submissions within the above time limit.
M. Submission of information on confidential basis
27. Any party making any confidential submission or providing information on confidential basis before the
Authority, is required to simultaneously submit a non-confidential version of the same in terms of Rule 8(2) of the
Rules and the Trade Notices issued in this regard. Failure to adhere to the above may lead to rejection of the
response/ submissions.
28. The parties making any submission (including Appendices/ Annexures attached thereto), before the
Authority including questionnaire response, are required to file Confidential and Non- Confidential versions
separately.
29. The "confidential" or "non-confidential" submissions must be clearly marked as "confidential" or "non-
confidential" at the top of each page. Any submission made without such marking shall be treated as non-
confidential by the Authority, and the Authority shall be at liberty to allow the other interested parties to inspect
such submissions.
30. The confidential version shall contain all information which is by nature confidential and/or other
information which the supplier of such information claims as confidential. For information which are claimed to
be confidential by nature or the information on which confidentiality is claimed because of other reasons, the
supplier of the information is required to provide a good cause statement along with the supplied information as
to why such information cannot be disclosed.
31. The non-confidential version of the information filed by the interested parties should be a replica of the
confidential version with the confidential information preferably indexed or blanked out (where indexation is not
possible) and such information must be appropriately and adequately summarized depending upon the
information on which confidentiality is claimed.
32. The non-confidential summary must be in sufficient detail to permit a reasonable understanding of the
substance of the information furnished on a confidential basis. However, in exceptional circumstances, the party
submitting the confidential information may indicate that such information is not susceptible to summary, and a
statement of reasons containing a sufficient and adequate explanation in terms of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1995, and
appropriate trade notices issued by the Authority, as to why such summarization is not possible, must be provided
to the satisfaction of the Authority.
33. The interested parties can offer their comments on the issues of confidentiality claimed by the domestic
industry within 7 days from the date of circulation of the non-confidential version of the documents in terms of
paragraph 23 of this initiation notification.
34. Any submission made without a meaningful non-confidential version thereof or a sufficient and adequate
cause statement in terms of Rule 8 of the Rules, and appropriate trade notices issued by the Authority, on the
confidentiality claim shall not be taken on record by the Authority.
35. The Authority may accept or reject the request for confidentiality on examination of the nature of the
information submitted. If the Authority is satisfied the request for confidentiality is not warranted or if the
supplier of the information is either unwilling to make the information public or to authorize its disclosure in
generalized or in summary form, it may disregard such information.
36. The Authority on being satisfied and accepting the need for confidentiality of the information provided,
shall not disclose it to any party without specific authorization of the party providing such information.
37. A list of registered interested parties will be uploaded on the DGTR's website along with the request
therein to all of them to email the non-confidential version of their submissions/response/information to all other
interested parties. Failure to circulate non- confidential version of submissions/response/information might lead to
consideration of an interested party as non-cooperative.
N. Non-cooperation
38. In case where an interested party refuses access to, or otherwise does not provide necessary information
within a reasonable period, or significantly impedes the investigation, the Authority may record its findings on the
basis of the facts available to it and make such recommendations to the Central Government as deemed fit.
ANANT SWARUP, Designated Authority
Uploaded by Dte. of Printing at Government of India Press, Ring Road, Mayapuri, New Delhi-110064
and Published by the Controller of Publications, Delhi-110054.
Login to read full text